“The Lawsuit You Never Saw Coming”: When Internal Missteps Lead to External Litigation

By Jesse David Eisenberg, Esq. | JDE Law Firm, PLLC

Some lawsuits feel inevitable. A missed payment. A contract breach. A partnership implosion.

Others hit your inbox with zero warning. A demand letter. A filed complaint. A process server.

And the shock isn’t just the legal claim — it’s that it stems from something your team did. Or didn’t do. Or failed to track.

The Hidden Risk Inside Your Own Business

Most business owners focus on what the other party did wrong. But lawsuits often originate in-house:

• An employee sent a poorly worded email that’s now Exhibit A
• Someone approved a change — but no written amendment exists
• Your team accepted partial delivery or late payments for months without objection

In litigation, silence is often interpreted as consent. Sloppy habits are seen as business norms.

Three Common Internal Errors That Trigger External Trouble

1. Verbal Approvals — Your ops manager says “yes” over the phone, but the agreement says only written modifications count
2. Inconsistent Enforcement — You waive late fees for six months, then suddenly demand them in court
3. Poor Documentation — You assumed “everyone knew the deal” — but no paper trail supports your version

Prevention Is a Legal Strategy

You don’t need to be paranoid. You need to be precise.

Smart companies do these three things now:

• Audit how deals are handled — not just what’s signed
• Train team members on contract language that actually matters
• Loop legal counsel in before agreements change mid-performance

You Can’t Fix What You Don’t See

By the time your first instinct is “This came out of nowhere,” the problem is already expensive.

📞 If you're wondering where your exposure is — let’s find it before someone else does:
www.jdelaw.nyc | NY: 718-966-0877 | NJ: 732-490-7120

My business is to protect your business.