“He Signed It — But We’re Still Getting Sued”: Why Personal Guarantees Don’t Always Protect You

By Jesse David Eisenberg, Esq. | JDE Law Firm, PLLC

Many business owners and lenders believe that a personal guarantee is an ironclad shield against default. In theory, it should force the guarantor to pay if the business falls short. In reality, however, the guarantee often proves less effective than expected — leaving parties exposed to costly litigation.

The Promise vs. The Reality

When someone signs a personal guarantee, the assumption is clear: the guarantor is on the hook. But when disputes arise, a closer legal examination often reveals loopholes, ambiguities, and even cases where the guarantee is unenforceable.

• Ambiguous Language: Vague or poorly drafted terms in the guarantee can lead to litigation over interpretation.
• Improper Execution or Documentation: A guarantee signed under duress or without proper legal formalities may be invalidated.
• Overlooking Financial Reality: Even a valid guarantee may be worthless if the guarantor lacks assets or income to satisfy the obligation.

Real-World Implications

In many cases, lenders and business owners come to realize that a signed guarantee does not automatically equate to enforceable security. Whether due to insufficient documentation, unclear terms, or an insolvent guarantor, enforcement can turn into a costly and time-consuming legal battle.

What Can You Do?

If you’re relying on a personal guarantee to secure your interests, consider these steps:

• Review the Document Thoroughly: Ensure that every clause is clear and enforceable.
• Assess the Guarantor’s Solvency: A guarantee is only as good as the signer’s ability to pay. Run background and asset checks when possible.
• Negotiate Stronger Terms: Where possible, include collateral requirements or provisions that trigger automatic payment without delay.
• Consult with Legal Experts: Regular contract audits can identify vulnerabilities before they become court problems.

Conclusion

Don’t assume that a signed personal guarantee is the final word on financial liability. Whether you’re a lender, business owner, or investor, understanding the limitations of these guarantees can help you avoid unexpected legal pitfalls.

📞 Schedule a consult with JDE Law Firm, PLLC:
www.jdelaw.nyc | NY: 718-966-0877 | NJ: 732-490-7120

My business is to protect your business.